With drafty windows and siding that has become discolored and warped due to many years of nor’easters and sticky summers, you may have thought about whether you should undertake both tasks at the same time. This is one of the most common queries we get at Home Makeover LLC, and in most cases, the answer is yes. Windows and siding installation done at the same time helps to preserve the building envelope, maintain a consistent exterior, and is cheaper than doing it separately.
However, the sequence of how the installation should be done is as important as the decision to do it. If you don’t install the components in the right sequence, you will end up with leaks, inconsistent trim, and paying double for the same labor. In the following, we discuss the right installation sequence, where the real savings come from, and window capping.
Why Does Replacing Windows and Siding at the Same Time Make Sense?
Windows and siding are not two separate components. There is an interface between these two, which occurs at every opening in the building, and it is at this point that exterior water damage begins. Installing new windows in old siding means cutting, patching, and caulking into materials that are about to reach their end of life. Installing new siding around old windows leaves the windows to continue living their life until they start failing, and in that case, some of that newly installed siding will have to be torn off.
Installing the two components simultaneously allows for full access to the wall surface. Once the old siding is stripped away, we will be able to inspect the sheathing, identify soft spots and rotted areas around openings, and fix any problems before they are covered by new materials. Such inspection becomes nearly impossible if only one of these components is being replaced. The other benefit you get is that all components will be coordinated in terms of colors and style, since all decisions are made simultaneously.
The Right Order: Windows First, Then Siding
In most cases, windows go in first, followed by siding. Every material that goes on an exterior wall should channel water away, down and out of the wall, as in shingled roofs. It is important to flash the windows properly into the weather-resistive barrier before siding covers it. It’s also important to know that window accessories such as J-channel have to meet finished window frames.
This is how the work would be done during our window and siding replacement job:
- Remove the existing siding and trim.
- Inspect and fix any problems related to the sheathing.
- House wrap should be installed from the bottom up. Each course overlaps with the next.
- Install new windows with sill pans and flashing tapes on sides and head.
- Siding should be installed after installing starter strips around openings and J-channel.
- Windows caps and trim should finish the job.
The good thing about our company is that there are cases where we install replacement windows in existing frames; so in those cases, no siding will have to be removed. What matters is the fact that both trades are under one roof since the inception of the project idea.
Where the Savings Come From?
Not all items become less expensive when bundling window and siding replacements, but the overall cost is cheaper compared to doing both projects separately. Most of the savings occur in some of the following areas:
- Only one mobilization, which refers to one installation, dumpster, staging, and clean-up costs.
- Shared labor at the openings because only one job is done for flashing, trim, and capping work.
- Avoiding the removal of new siding to get access to the windows that were not installed during the first job.
- Reduced permit fees and inspections, if applicable.
There is also a payoff in the long run. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, about 25 to 30 percent of energy used by residential homes in the process of heating and cooling results from gains and losses of heat via windows. Combine energy-efficient windows, such as dual-pane windows with low-e glass, and insulation with new siding applied on top of a properly sealed wall surface, and you will reduce drafts in two of the weakest spots of your house.
Window Capping: The Finishing Step Many Homeowners Overlook
Window capping, also known as trim wrap or aluminum wrap, wraps exterior wood window trim, sills, and brickmold in custom-bent aluminum or PVC-coated coil stock. Measuring each opening and fitting the material to fit tight on the trim to ensure protection from rain, snow, and sunshine in New Jersey.
Exposed wood trim is what first becomes rotten on many New Jersey homes, specifically old colonials, Cape Cods, and split levels with original painted casings. Once it becomes cased, it will never need scraping and painting, and the windows will become nicely framed in the same colors as your new siding.
Wood should be checked for rot and replaced where necessary before the metal can go up. This will help since capping rotting wood will only hide the problem. Joints of the metal should overlap in the direction of water flow. Use sealant that will prevent water from getting behind the metal but not trap moisture inside. Doing window capping with the rest of the project makes for better matching of colors and profiles, and it is harder to get right if spread out over many years.
What New Jersey Homeowners Should Know Before Starting?
Our climate is not forgiving of anything. The freeze-thaw cycle, driving rain from the coast, and summer humidity can take their toll on windows and siding. It is best to talk about vinyl, fiber cement, or engineered wood siding in our climate since they can all do a great job as long as they are put in correctly.
The season can also have an effect on your decision. It is good to do your exterior renovations in either spring or fall, as temperatures in New Jersey are moderate at those times. It will be harder to work with vinyl in winter, as it becomes brittle.
Requirements for permits also depend on each municipality. In some of the towns, replacement of similar products may not need a building permit since it is considered a minor alteration according to the state code. However, if your house was built prior to 1978, there are federal regulations regarding safe work practices on painted surfaces.
Why NJ Homeowners Choose Home Makeover LLC?
At Home Makeover LLC, our window and siding replacement projects go hand in hand, run by the same team throughout the entire process. This means that you get one point of contact, one schedule, and one crew handling all the seams between windows and siding. We take the time to assess the condition of the structure underneath the siding, share what we learn, and only recommend the work that your home needs.
Our estimators will walk your property, take measurements of all openings, and show you options for windows, siding, and capping.
Final Thoughts
One of the most cost-effective exterior renovation projects you can do to your house in New Jersey is replacing windows and siding simultaneously. Get the windows done, flash the windows correctly on the weather-resistant barrier membrane, do the siding, and then do the capping. When you do that in such a sequence, not only do you save money, but the work will look great, and your house will be much better protected compared to doing each job separately.
When your windows need replacement, when the exterior siding of your house has gone out of style, and when the trim needs replacing because of rot, now is the time to plan. Contact Home Makeover LLC to schedule a home consultation. Your house exterior will be examined, and a detailed estimate will be provided.
About the Author: Jeffrey W. Nero
Jeffrey W. Nero is a home improvement expert with over 20 years of experience serving homeowners in New Jersey. As the owner of Home Makeover™, Jeff combines quality craftsmanship with a deep understanding of local needs. From roofing and siding to deck remodels, Jeff has helped thousands of homeowners bring their visions to life. His commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction makes him a trusted partner in transforming homes across Central NJ.

